Skip to main content
Order our cheesecakes straight to your door!

Become a VIP and receive $5 off!

CLICK HERE
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 2/1.
Diner Hospitality Group
  • Mill Plain Diner
    Mill Plain Diner Printable Menu
  • Mystic Diner
    Mystic Diner Printable Menu
  • Parthenon Diner
    Branford Old Saybrook Printable Menu
  • About Us
  • Private Events
  • Contact Us
    Send a Message Join Our Team
old timey cargirl with burger

Mystic Diner Menu

Become a VIP and receive $5 OFFReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Mystic Diner Menu

House Specialties

Hungry Man
11000

Hungry Man

$152 eggs, 2 Pancakes, Home Fries, Sausage, Bacon and Ham

11000
00000

Pastrami & Eggs

$11Hot pastrami served with sliced tomatoes, home fries & toast.

00000
Blueberry Waffle Deluxe
00000

Blueberry Waffle Deluxe

$13Crisp waffle topped with fresh blueberries with (2) eggs and bacon, ham or sausage – no substitutions

00000
20002

Eggs, Home Fries & Toast

With bacon, sausage or ham1 Egg $52 eggs $6Add Canadian Bacon or Turkey Sausage +$2Egg white +$1Add canadian bacon or turkey sausage +$2.50With Corned Beef Hash +$3Add bacon, sausage or ham +$2Add avocado +$2Substitute english muffin or bagel +$1Substitute fresh baked muffin +$1.50

20002
00000

Philly Steak & Eggs

$12Shaved steak with peppers, onions, mushrooms & Swiss. Served with home fries & toast.

00000

Poached

Classic Eggs Benedict
40031

Classic Eggs Benedict

$122 poached eggs with grilled Canadian bacon served on a grilled English muffin topped with hollandaise and served with home fries

40031
00000

Irish Benedict

$132 poached eggs with hash served on a grilled English muffin topped with hollandaise and served with home fries

00000
California Benedict
10001

California Benedict

$132 poached eggs with crispy bacon & avocado served on a grilled English muffin topped with hollandaise and served with home fries

10001
20002

Crab Cake Benedict

$15.502 poached eggs with jumbo lump crab cakes with a hint of Cajun seasoning on a grilled English muffin topped with hollandaise and served with home fries

20002

Mystic Diner's Top Omelets

All omelets served with home fries & toast (unless noted) 

Omelette Extra Fixins:
American, Cheddar, Swiss, Mozzarella, Jack Cheese, Onions, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Tomato, Spinach | 1 Each
Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Sautéed Onions, Sautéed Mushrooms | 1.50 Each
Turkey Sausage, Canadian Bacon, Blue Cheese Crumbles, Feta, Goat Cheese, Brie | 1.75 Each
Avocado | 2.50
Fresh Roasted Turkey | 6

Cheese
00000

Cheese

$8Feta +$8

00000
00000

Vegetarian

$9Peppers, onions, mushrooms & tomatoes

00000
VG
00000

Greek

$10Feta cheese, fresh spinach, tomato & kalamata olives

00000
VG
20002

Light Heart Healthy

$10Egg white omelet with mushrooms, chives, broccoli & tomato served with cottage cheese on the side

20002
VG
Kostas
00000

Kostas

$10Sausage, cheddar cheese & onions

00000
Western
20011

Western

$10Ham, peppers & onions

20011
Bacon, Ham or Sausage, and Cheese
00000

Bacon, Ham or Sausage, and Cheese

$9.50

00000
00000

Mexican

$10Avocado, cheddar cheese, salsa, sour cream & chives

00000
00000

Bacon, Tomato & Cheddar

$10

00000
10001

Malibu

$11Avocado, artichoke, tomato & jack cheese

10001
VG
00000

Spinach, Mushroom & Swiss

$10

00000
00000

Spicy Hot Mardi Gras

$11Sausage, peppers, jalapeños, onions, tomatoes, mushrooms & jack cheese

00000

Try Something Different...

00000

Sliced Tomatoes

$1Instead of home fries

00000
Sweet Fries
10010

Sweet Fries

$2Instead of home fries

10010
00000

English Muffin

$1Or bagel instead of toast

00000
00000

Side Salad

$2Instead of home fries

00000
00000

Cottage Cheese

$2Instead of home fries

00000
00000

Egg Whites

$1.50Instead of whole eggs

00000
00000

Gluten Free Bread

$2Instead of toast

00000

Griddles

Buttermilk Pancakes
00000

Buttermilk Pancakes

Short Stack (2) $6Full Stack (3) $7.50

00000
00000

Banana Pecan Pancakes

Short stack (2) $8Full stack (3) $10

00000
Mystic French Toast
30012

Mystic French Toast

$12With strawberry, banana & sweet cream cheese filling topped with vanilla rum sauce

30012
Hawaiian French Toast
00000

Hawaiian French Toast

$133 egg dipped pineapple bread topped with toasted coconut, macadamia nuts & bananas

00000
10001

Challah Bread French Toast

Short Stack (2) $6Full Stack (3) $7.50

10001
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
00000

Chocolate Chip Pancakes

Short Stack (2) $7Full Stack (3) $8.50

00000
Fruity Pancakes
00000

Fruity Pancakes

$123 pancakes topped with strawberries, blueberries, bananas, raspberry drizzle & powdered sugar

00000
Plain Belgian Waffle
10001

Plain Belgian Waffle

$7.50Strawberries, Blueberries, or Bananas +$2.50

10001

Breakfast Sandwiches

Served with Home Fries or French Fries on a hard roll, grilled sourdough or choice of bread

00000

Bacon, 2 Eggs & Cheese

$6

00000
00000

Philly Steak, 2 Eggs & Cheese

$8Shaved steak topped with onions, peppers & mushrooms

00000
11000

Avocado Toast

$8Bacon, avocado & tomato on toasted sourdoughAdd lox +$5Add 2 Eggs +$2Add LOX +$5Add two eggs +$2

11000
00000

Sunrise Breakfast Burrito

$92 scrambled eggs, cheddar cheese, potatoes, peppers, onions & bacon, ham or sausage

00000
00000

Ham, Egg & Cheese

1 Egg $3.692 Eggs $4.69

00000
00000

NY Bagel

$10Lox, cream cheese, tomato, onion and capers. Choice of plain, everything or sesame bagel

00000
00000

Turkey Sausage, 2 Eggs & Cheese

$7

00000
00000

Short Rib Hash, 2 Eggs & Cheese

$8Served on grilled sourdough

00000
00000

California Grilled Cheese

$8.50Bacon, avocado, tomato & cheese on grilled sourdoughAdd 2 Eggs +$2

00000
10010

Sausage, Egg & Cheese

1 Egg $3.692 Eggs $4.69

10010
00000

Western Egg & Cheese

1 Egg $4.292 Eggs $5.29

00000

Breakfast Sides

00000

Greek Yogurt Parfait

$6Greek yogurt, topped with granola, honey on side

00000
00000

Home Fries or French Fries

$4

00000
00000

Bacon, Ham or Sausage

$3.75

00000
00000

Turkey Sausage or Canadian Bacon

$4.50

00000
00000

Avocado

$2.50

00000
Side Toast
00000

Side Toast

$1.75

00000
00000

Capers

$1

00000
Bagel
00000

Bagel

$2Plain, Sesame or Everything

00000
00000

Side of Grilled Pita

$2.75

00000
00000

Side Salad

$5

00000
00000

Greek Sundae

$9Split banana, 2 scoops yogurt, topped with strawberries, blueberries & granola, honey on the side

00000
Sweet Potato Fries
00000

Sweet Potato Fries

$6

00000
00000

Seasonal Fresh Fruit Cup

$4

00000
00000

Corned Beef Hash

$6

00000
00000

English Muffin

$1.80

00000
00000

Cottage Cheese

$3

00000
00000

Home Baked Muffin

$2.75

00000
00000

Side of Lox

$6.50

00000
00000

Sliced Tomatoes

$1.50

00000

Beverages

00000

Bottomless Coffee

$2.80

00000
00000

Herbal Tea

$3

00000
00000

Milk

Small $2.80Large $3.75

00000
00000

Egg Cream

$5Chocolate or vanilla

00000
00000

Juice

Small $3Large $4

00000
00000

Flavor Shot

$1Caramel, Vanilla, Coconut, Hazelnut

00000
00000

Tea

$2.80

00000
00000

Hot Chocolate

$2.76

00000
00000

Chocolate Milk

Small $3Large $4

00000
00000

Iced Coffee

$3

00000
00000

Chocolate or Vanilla Boston Egg Cream

$5

00000
00000

Soda

$2.50Free refill with dine in only.

00000

Lunch

Served after 11:00 am

Appetizers

00000

Chili Cheese Loaded Fries

$9Topped with chopped bacon, jalapeños, chili, American & cheddar cheese with ranch dressing on the side

00000
11000

Fried Mozzarella

$8Served with marinara sauce

11000
00000

Cajun Clam Strips

$11Served with chipotle aioli

00000
Chicken Wings
10001

Chicken Wings

$12Tossed in your choice of BBQ, buffalo or garlic and parmesan sauce

10001
00000

Crispy Pork Dumplings

$10Diced sesame ginger pork rolled inside a delicate wonton wrapper served with sweet chili sauce

00000
00000

Garlic Parmesan Fries

$8Crispy fries with garlic herb butter and grated parmesan cheese

00000
00000

Chicken Tenders

$10

00000
10010

Mac & Cheese Bites

$9

10010
00000

Fried Calamari

$11

00000
Chipotle Quesadilla
00000

Chipotle Quesadilla

$11Fresh tortilla filled with jack cheese, tomato, bacon, chipotle

00000

Soup & Salad

00000

Farm Salad

$9Mixed greens, tomatoes, cucumbers & red onion served with grilled pita

00000
VG
00000

Taco Salad

$14Tortilla basket filled with romaine, chili, kalamata olives, red onion, jalapeños, pico de gallo & cheddar cheese served with salsa, sour cream and guacamole on the side

00000
00000

Savannah Tuna Salad

$14Low fat tuna salad with cucumber, tomato, a diced hard boiled egg, cranberries & sliced apples over mixed greens served with grilled pita, oil & vinegar on the side

00000
Crock of French Onion Soup
00000

Crock of French Onion Soup

$6.50

00000
00000

Chicken Noodle

Cup $4.50Bowl $5.50

00000
House Made Chili
00000

House Made Chili

Cup $5Bowl $6

00000
Chicken Caesar Salad
00000

Chicken Caesar Salad

$12Grilled chicken served over romaine, topped with croutons & parmesan cheese served with grilled pita

00000
00000

Chef Salad

$14Roast beef, turkey, ham, Swiss, American, cheddar, a diced hard boiled egg, tomato & cucumber over mixed greens served with grilled pita

00000
Cobb Salad
00000

Cobb Salad

$15Roast turkey, avocado, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, tomato, & a diced hard boiled egg over mixed greens served with grilled Pita

00000
New England Clam Chowder
00000

New England Clam Chowder

Clams, leeks, onions, celery & potatoes with a hint of bacon in a creamy clam brothCup $5Bowl $6

00000
00000

Soup of the Day

Ask your server Cup $4.50Bowl $5.50

00000
00000

Seafood Bisque

Ask your server if it is availableCup $5.50Bowl $7

00000

Sandwiches, Handhelds, and Gourmet Burgers

Served with French fries, Cole slaw & pickle (unless noted)

00000

Veggie Burger

$12Grilled vegetable patty with avocado, lettuce tomato & side salad (NO FRIES)

00000
00000

Turkey Burger

$128 oz. freshly ground grilled turkey with lettuce & tomato

00000
00000

Mystic Burger

$13With bacon, sautéed onions, mushrooms, cheddar, lettuce, tomato and smokehouse BBQ sauce

00000
00000

Pattie Melt

$12.50½ lb. burger with Swiss cheese & sautéed onion on grilled marble rye

00000
00000

Mystic Panini

$12Fresh roast turkey, bacon, tomato, cheddar cheese & Dijon horseradish dressing

00000
Chicken Pesto Panini
00000

Chicken Pesto Panini

$12.50Grilled chicken, basil, pesto, tomato & mozzarella

00000
00000

Veggie Wrap

$11Grilled fresh garden vegetables with feta cheese

00000
VG
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
10001

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$12Chicken tenders with medium buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, red onion & bleu cheese dressing

10001
Philly Sandwich
00000

Philly Sandwich

$13Philly steak with onions, peppers, mushrooms & Swiss cheese

00000
00000

Monte Cristo

$12.25Sliced turkey, ham & melted Swiss cheese served between golden brown French toast

00000
Classic Burger
10001

Classic Burger

$11½ lb. black angus burger with lettuce & tomato

10001
00000

Turkey Club

$11Triple decker with roast turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato & mayo on toast

00000
00000

Mushroom & Swiss Burger

$13Classic burger with sautéed mushrooms, Swiss cheese, lettuce & tomato

00000
Bacon Bleu Cheese Burger
00000

Bacon Bleu Cheese Burger

$13With crispy bacon, sautéed onion, bleu cheese crumbles, lettuce & tomato

00000
French Dip Panini
00000

French Dip Panini

$13Roast sirloin of beef with Swiss cheese & caramelized onions served with au jus on the side

00000
00000

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$13Grilled chicken, hearts of romaine, parmesan cheese & Caesar dressing

00000
10001

Cod Filet Sandwich

$12.50Beer battered fresh cod filet served on hard roll with tarter sauce

10001
20002

Harvest Turkey Wrap

$13Roast turkey with brie, apples, walnuts, mixed lettuce & honey Dijon dressing

20002
00000

Corned Beef/Pastrami Reuben

$13With sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, & Russian dressing served on grilled marble rye

00000
00000

Chipotle Chicken Burger

$12Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomato, raw onion, jalapeños, cheddar cheese and chipotle aioli

00000

Classics

Served with Fries, Cole Slaw & Pickle

00000

NY Hot Dog

$7Add Sauerkraut +$1

00000
00000

BLT Sandwich

$8

00000
00000

Open Roast Beef Sandwich

$14Sliced hot roast beef served with mashed potatoes and brown gravy

00000
Low Fat Tuna Sandwich
00000

Low Fat Tuna Sandwich

$11Tuna salad with apples, red onion, celery

00000
Grilled Cheese
10001

Grilled Cheese

$7

10001
00000

Open Turkey Sandwich

$14Sliced hot turkey served with mashed potatoes, turkey gravy & cranberry sauce

00000
00000

Tuna Melt

$11Tuna salad grilled with tomato & melted American cheese

00000
Turkey or Roast Beef Deli Sandwich
00000

Turkey or Roast Beef Deli Sandwich

$10Served with lettuce & tomato on bread choice

00000

Greek Specialties

Served after 11am

00000

Moussaka

$16Layers of eggplant & ground beef, baked with cheese soufflé topping served with a cup of soup or a side salad

00000
10010

Chicken Souvlaki on Pita Bread

$14Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion, kalamata olives, feta cheese & tzatziki sauce served with French fries, Cole slaw & pickle

10010
Greek Salad
00000

Greek Salad

$12.50Feta cheese, kalamata olives, stuffed grape leaves, tomatoes & cucumbers over mixed greens with olive oil & vinegar on the side

00000
10001

Gyro

$12.50Your choice of chicken or lamb with lettuce, tomato, onion & tzatziki sauce served with French fries, Cole slaw & pickle

10001
Greek Vegetarian Platter
00000

Greek Vegetarian Platter

$14Spinach pie, stuffed grape leaves, feta cheese, pita bread, tzatziki sauce, kalamata olives, lettuce & tomato

00000
VG
Spanakopita
00000

Spanakopita

$16Spinach & feta cheese wrapped in filo dough, served with a cup of soup or a side salad

00000

Gluten Free / Paleo

Served after 11am

00000

Diane

$12Grilled London broil, sauted broccoli rabe, garlic, olive oil.

00000
Nancy
10001

Nancy

$13Grilled chicken breast served with mushrooms, broccoli, & diced tomatoes topped with melted mozzarella

10001
00000

Kimberly

$136 oz grilled London broil with sautéed broccoli in garlic & olive oil

00000
00000

Ethan

$12Twin 5 oz. hamburgers, 2 eggs over easy, grilled onions, lettuce, tomatoes.

00000
10001

Jessica

$12(3) Lettuce wraps filled with grilled chicken, bacon, shredded cheddar, diced tomato, raw onion & ranch dressing

10001
10001

Kenneth

$13Iceberg lettuce bed with strawberries, blue cheese crumbles, red onion, walnuts and avocado & Grilled Chicken, served with your choice of dressing on the side

10001

Additions

00000

Sauerkraut

$1

00000
00000

Bacon, Ham, Sautéed Onions, Mushrooms, Peppers

$1.50

00000
00000

Avocado

$2.50

00000
00000

Cole Slaw

$2.50

00000
00000

Grilled Chicken

$5

00000
00000

Tuna Salad or Chicken Salad

$4.50

00000
Cheese
00000

Cheese

$1American, Swiss, Mozzarella, Cheddar, Jalapeño Jack Cheese

00000
00000

Chili

$2

00000
00000

Peanut Butter

$1.50

00000
00000

Blue Cheese Crumbles, Feta, Goat Cheese, Brie

$1.75

00000
00000

Grilled Shrimp

$7

00000

Try Something Different

Instead of French Fries | 2

00000

Waffle Fries

00000
00000

Side Salad

00000
00000

Cup of Soup

00000
Sweet Fries
10010

Sweet Fries

10010
00000

Cottage Cheese

00000
Onion Rings
00000

Onion Rings

00000

Dinner Menu

After 4pm
All dinner items served with a cup of soup or a side salad & a dinner roll with cinnamon butter

Entrees

00000

Baked Chicken Parmigiana

$17Served with spaghetti

00000
00000

Chicken Francaise

$18Grilled chicken breast in butter, lemon & white wine served over rice pilaf

00000
00000

Baked Meatloaf

$16Served with mashed potatoes, brown gravy & vegetables

00000
Yankee Pot Roast
00000

Yankee Pot Roast

$17Served with mashed potatoes & honey carrots

00000
00000

Spaghetti & Meatballs

$16Served with garlic bread

00000
00000

Chicken Pesto Penne

$16Grilled chicken and roasted red peppers served over penne tossed in creamy pesto sauce

00000
Fresh Roasted Turkey
00000

Fresh Roasted Turkey

$18Served with apple stuffing, mashed potatoes, vegetables & cranberry sauce

00000
00000

Teriyaki Ribeye

$2414 oz. rib eye steak in a teriyaki glaze served with a starch of your choice & vegetables

00000
10001

Fettuccine Alfredo

$17Linguini topped with grilled chicken breast in a cream sauce & parmesan cheese

10001

Seafood

Fish & Chips
00000

Fish & Chips

$19Beer battered cod, French fries & cole slaw served with tartar sauce on the side

00000
00000

Stonington Sea Scallops

$25Fresh local sea scallops broiled to perfection with sea salt & lemon butter sauce served with a starch of your choice & vegetables

00000
00000

Mystic Fisherman Platter

$25A combination of fried shrimp, clam strips, cod & calamari served with fries, Cole slaw, tartar sauce, cocktail sauce & marinara on the side

00000
00000

Seafood Fra Diavolio

$18Broiled scallops & grilled shrimp served over linguini in a spicy red tomato sauce

00000
00000

Ribs & Fried Shrimp

$23½ rack of baby back ribs slowly cooked, served with fried shrimp, French fries, cole slaw & cocktail sauce on the side

00000
00000

New England Baked Scrod

$22Fresh lemon, white wine, butter & bread crumbs served with a starch of your choice & vegetables

00000
10001

Seafood Sampler

$242 jumbo crab cakes, grilled shrimp & fried calamari served with a baked potato & vegetables

10001
00000

Shrimp Scampi

$20Grilled jumbo shrimp with tomatoes in butter & garlic served over rice pilaf

00000

Our Famous New England Lobster Roll

Market Price/Seasonal

Hot Lobster Roll
20020

Hot Lobster Roll

Fresh lobster meat served hot on a grilled 6-inch buttered hot dog roll served with French fries, cole slaw & pickle

20020
00000

Cold Lobster Roll

Fresh lobster meat with minced onion, celery, seasoning, mayonnaise & butter on a 6-inch hot dog roll served with French fries, cole slaw & pickle

00000

Lunch/Dinner Sides

00000

French Fries

$4

00000
00000

Side Grape Leaves

$7

00000
00000

Baked Potato

$3

00000
00000

Vegetable of the Day

$3

00000
00000

Side Penne Pasta

$4

00000
00000

Sweet Fries, Onion Rings, or Waffle Fries

$6

00000
00000

Mashed Potatoes

$3

00000
11000

Rice Pilaf

$3

11000
00000

Side Salad

$5

00000

Beverages

Cappuccino
10001

Cappuccino

$4.95

10001
00000

Latte

$4.95

00000
00000

Espresso

$4.50

00000

Mystic Diner's Milkshakes

6

00000

Pick Me up Shake

Vanilla ice cream with espresso & oreo

00000
Death by Chocolate
00000

Death by Chocolate

Chocolate ice cream & chocolate chips with chocolate syrup

00000
00000

Tropical Breeze

Vanilla ice cream & coco-loco milk with pineapple juice

00000
00000

Shamrock Shake

Mint chocolate chip ice cream with chocolate syrup

00000
00000

Mango Milkless Shake

Mango sorbet & pineapple juice

00000
00000

Mystic Sea Turtle

Maple walnut & vanilla ice cream with caramel & chocolate syrup

00000
00000

German Chocolate Shake

Chocolate ice cream, coco-loco milk & caramel topped with toasted coconut

00000
00000

So Berry Good

Strawberry & blueberry ice cream with raspberry syrup

00000
10001

Peanut Butter Caramel Explosion

Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter & caramel syrup

10001
00000

Creamsicle Shake

Vanilla ice cream & orange juice

00000

Specialty Coffees

6

00000

Raspberry Mocha Iced Coffee a La Mode

Vanilla ice cream, raspberry & chocolate syrup with iced coffee

00000
00000

Samoa Iced Coffee a La Mode

Vanilla ice cream, chocolate & caramel syrup with coco-loco & topped with toasted coconut

00000
00000

Coconut Cream Pie a La Mode

Coco-loco milk and iced coffee topped with toasted coconut

00000
00000

Salted Caramel Mocha Latte

Espresso, caramel & chocolate syrup, sea salt with steamed milk

00000
00000

Black Forest a La Mode

Cherry vanilla ice cream, iced coffee & hot fudge

00000
00000

Vanilla Hazelnut Iced Coffee

Vanilla ice cream with caramel & hazelnut syrup shaken with iced coffee

00000

Yimello Smoothies

6

00000

South Beach

Pineapple, mango, banana and orange juice

00000
00000

Berry Blast

Strawberry, blueberry, banana cranberry juice & sweet iced tea

00000
00000

Strawberry Banana

Strawberry, banana and orange juice

00000

House Made Desserts

See your server or the dessert case for a complete list of desserts, We have a huge selection that changes daily!

Our Famous Cheesecake
00000

Our Famous Cheesecake

$5

00000
00000

Fruit Pies

$4

00000
00000

Rice Pudding

$4

00000
00000

Home Baked Muffin

$2.75

00000
Lovely Layer Cakes
00000

Lovely Layer Cakes

$6

00000
00000

Tapioca Pudding

$4

00000
10001

Jumbo Cookie

$2

10001
Show All Items
VGVegetarian